Article: Red flags in a workplace: Identifying toxic culture signs

Ever had a colleague who works tirelessly, day and night, solely to earn the label of a 'hard worker' and snag the star employee of the month award? Their dedication might seem commendable, but it often puts pressure on their coworkers to match their level of productivity. This behaviour isn't just about personal achievement; it's often praised by the leadership team, perpetuating a toxic work culture. What may have once been seen as dedication can actually be a sign of toxicity in today's evolving workplaces. This includes the expectation for employees to consistently exceed what's realistically achievable for the average worker.

The repercussions of a toxic workplace extend beyond individual employees; they can significantly impair overall organisational performance. Negative employee morale is detrimental to the health of a thriving workplace. While many workplaces are making strides towards fostering healthier and more positive cultures, it remains crucial to recognise subtle signs of toxicity that could jeopardise your workplace and drive away valuable talent.

Here are the key signs of a toxic workplace that you need to identify and address now!

#1 Poor management and communication

Strict communication hierarchies cause misunderstandings, frustration, and a lack of trust among team members. The cues to identify these signs of poor communication include - unclear expectations, withholding information, and a reluctance to address concerns openly. Additionally, micromanagement by leadership team stifles employees, making them feel undervalued and disempowered. If managers or team leads excessively control or scrutinise every aspect of their team member’s work, it can hinder creativity, autonomy, and innovation.

#2 Office politics

Politics in the workplace encompass gossip, favouritism, bullying, and backstabbing behaviours. These toxic actions can ruin the work culture, leading to a sense of distrust among employees. When there's a lack of clear career progression policies, personal agendas and rivalries may take precedence over professional objectives, resulting in diminished productivity and morale. To address these issues, HR and talent professionals need to establish clear career progression frameworks, accountabilities, and KPIs for all employees throughout the organisation, including for leadership roles.

#3 Increasing disengagement and quiet quitters

Increasing disengagement in workplaces is a subtle sign of workplace toxicity. Employees may disengage from their work, only putting in the bare minimum effort, while secretly exploring new opportunities without informing their organisation. These 'quiet quitters' may appear engaged on the surface but are mentally checked out and disengaged from their work. How do you spot disengaged employees? Look for their lack of enthusiasm, minimal participation in meetings, disinterest in company goals, or consistent underperformance. If left unaddressed, it can signal deeper issues within the organisation, including increased silent disengagement and lack of motivation, contributing to a negative environment. HR leaders need to implement effective engagement strategies that strengthen employee relations, improve retention rates, and enhance overall performance and productivity company-wide.

#4 Painful HR processes

HR processes and work policies that are outdated, rigid, or insensitive can contribute to a toxic work culture too. How? Think of overly bureaucratic processes, unfair performance evaluation systems, or inadequate support for employees facing personal challenges, all these can lead to frustration and resentment among workers. HR and talent leaders can improve the employee experience by embracing digitisation and technology. This could involve implementing digital solutions for recruitment and onboarding processes, providing self-service portals for employees, automating performance management and recruitment processes, establishing learning management systems for training, and leveraging data analytics for decision-making.

These initiatives not only streamline HR processes but also effectively enhance the employee experience, leading to improved engagement, retention, and overall organisational success.

#5 Missing ERGs

Employee Resource Groups (ERGs) play a vital role in fostering diversity, inclusion, and a sense of belonging within organisations. When companies fail to establish or support ERGs, it can indicate a lack of commitment to creating an inclusive workplace culture where all employees feel valued and supported.

How to address it? HR can establish effective ERGs by defining their purpose and objectives in alignment with DEI goals, securing leadership support, and fostering diversity and inclusivity. By establishing clear structure and governance, allocating resources, promoting networking and engagement, collaborating with HR, and measuring impact and progress through regular evaluation, HR can ensure a supportive environment for employees to connect, share experiences, and drive initiatives that contribute to a diverse, inclusive, and engaged workforce.

#6 Disturbed work-life balance and well-being

Are your employees working beyond office hours? Are they struggling to meet deadlines? Do they consistently report increasing stress in surveys? These are signs of a lack of work-life balance. Additionally, pay attention to physical symptoms like increased absenteeism, unexplained illnesses, or emotional signs such as mood swings, anxiety, or depression among employees. Organisations that expect employees to work long hours without sufficient rest or personal time risk burnout, resentment, and high turnover rates.

To promote employee well-being and sustained productivity, it's crucial to establish effective goals, responsibilities, and KPIs. Additionally, tracking employee performance goals can help identify and streamline responsibilities that may be overwhelming or stressful for them.

#7 Unclear goals and expectations

When employees lack clarity about their roles or how their work fits into the organisation's goals, it can cause confusion, disengagement, and low motivation. If your employees remain clueless about their work and responsibilities even after the probation period, it's an alarming issue. If the organisation doesn’t take steps to establish clear work policies for employees, it’s likely to be an unhealthy workplace. Communicating a crystal-clear plan for employees is crucial to maintaining a healthy and transparent workforce. Implementing effective training and orientation programmes for employees and holding quarterly state-of-the-company meetings can greatly benefit your organisation. These initiatives help employees understand the company's short-term and long-term goals and how they can contribute to achieving them.

You may also like:

#8 Bullying, harassment and biasness

Any form of bullying, discrimination, or harassment in the workplace creates a toxic culture that can seriously impact employee mental health and well-being. It's crucial for organisations to establish clear policies and procedures to address and prevent such behaviour. When certain employees receive preferential treatment or are held to different standards than others, it breeds resentment and erodes trust within the team. Fairness and equity are essential for fostering a positive work environment, especially, for women to feel supported and included in the workplace.

HR can identify signs of toxic culture by encouraging employees to report incidents through confidential channels, reviewing complaints and grievances for patterns, and providing comprehensive training on recognising and preventing such behaviours. Additionally, monitoring performance evaluations and feedback, observing workplace interactions, conducting exit interviews and surveys, regularly reviewing policies and procedures, analysing HR data for correlations, and conducting anonymous surveys or climate assessments can be beneficial. By employing these methods, HR can proactively address issues and foster a respectful, inclusive, and equitable work environment.

#9 Lack of flexible work policies

Modern workplaces require flexibility to foster a high-performance culture where employees feel a sense of belonging. How do you know if your organisation lacks flexibility or resists change? Signs include: a lack of alternative work models, poor communication, reluctance from leadership in decision-making and approval processes, disregard for individual needs or preferences, low employee engagement or morale, limited career development opportunities, outdated policies, lack of trust, and high turnover or burnout rates. Embracing innovation and adaptability is crucial for staying competitive and maintaining employee engagement.

HR can assess the level of flexibility in their work policies and make adjustments as needed to better support employee well-being, productivity, and organisational success. This includes implementing flexible work arrangements, such as hybrid or remote work options, flexible hours, and creating a culture that values and encourages adaptability and innovation for a more dynamic and resilient workplace that meets the evolving needs of employees and the business.